“I don’t know how God can offend anybody,” New Jersey town wins Establishment Clause “No Doi” award

From the Poccino Record:

A nearly six-decade tradition of reciting the Lord’s Prayer at the start of Town Council meetings has ended.

The tradition, begun in 1952, stopped Monday night after a single resident’s objection. It’s the end of a popular tradition that pleased more than it dismayed, according to the five council members, all of whom described themselves as saddened by the change but resigned to the realities of court precedent.

“According to our counsel, (the prayer) is a violation of the First Amendment,” said Councilwoman Helen LeFrois.

No doi. But the article gets better:

It’s not the first time the Lord’s Prayer has been publicly questioned in Newton. In March 1995, the council began debating the values of switching the tradition to a secular prayer because a Jewish councilman, Robert Shapiro, had been elected to the council.

Shapiro adamantly supported the Lord’s Prayer tradition [?!??-ed.] and the recitation continued. Shapiro, who now lives in Florida, said he was disappointed to hear the controversy being brought up again.

“These are the traditions our country is founded upon,” he said, citing the mottos that dot U.S. government buildings — and even its currency.

“It says, ‘In God We Trust.’ That’s a lot older than the Newton Town Council,” Shapiro said.

[Actually, “In God We Trust” as the “U.S. Motto” is not older than the Newton Town Counsel, unless TV is older than the Newton Town Counsel, and it is not older than the city, which has a “rich historic heritage dating back to 1751“. – ed.]

Ray Storm, a three-time Newton mayor and four-term councilman, said he was discouraged by the abandonment of tradition, even if it was due to court precedent.

“In my mind, I don’t know how God can offend anybody,” Storm said. [No comment. –ed.]

I am not intending to demean anyone’s religion, or their particular view of God.  But the recital of the prayer Jesus taught while hanging on the cross, slowly dying at the hands of the Romans and Jews, is sectarian.  The leaders of the town are calling upon a particular God to give them particular guidance on governmental powers is nearly as close to “establishment of religion” as you can get.  While there may be a zone of religious activity permissible by the Constitution–in fact, the counsel members may even have a First Amendment Free Exercise right to provide personal declarations of faith, a Christian prayer before a counsel meeting doesn’t fit.  It’s actions like this that bring counter-actions, like Michael Newdow’s latest suit to stop President-Elect Obama from saying “so help me God” during the inauguration.  More on that action later.


Advertisements

Leave a comment

Filed under First Amendment, Law, Society

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s