Real CourtTV– Judge Nancy Gerner allows live streaming of oral argument

As reported by ComputerWorld here, United States District Judge Nancy Gertner has agreed to allow a streaming webcast of an oral argument occurring on January 22 in Capitol Records v. Alaujan and Sony BMG Music Entertainment v. Tenenbaum.  The oral argument is on Mr. Tenenbaum’s Motions to Amend Counterclaims, opposition to the record companies’ Motion to Dismiss the Counterclaims, and a Motion for Joinder of the RIAA.  Mr. Tenenbaum, a Boston University Ph.D. candidate, has been accused of using peer-to-peer file sharing to download music.  He got an attorney– Charles Nesson, professor of law at Harvard and of the Berkman Center for Internet and Society.

Because the proceedings on January 22 are only oral argument, the Court reasoned, “narrowcasting” the proceedings will not influence the performance of any witnesses or testimony. And, because the record companies hope to discourage illegal file sharing through general deterrence built up from the publicity of lawsuits across the country, the Court was “curios” as to why the record companies objected to the motion.  Therefore, the Court reasoned:

The public benefit of offering a more complete view of these proceedings is plain, especially via a medium so carefully attuned to the Internet Generation captivated by these filesharing lawsuits.

The Courtroom View Network (CVN) will create the narrowcast using the cameras (likely to be fairly low-res security cameras and monitors) already installed in the courtroom, and the Berkman Center will rebroadcast on http://cyber.law.harvard.edu.  I’ll be tuning in to hear Professor Nesson’s arguments regarding the constitutionality of the fines potentially imposed by the Copyright Act, as well as the Digital Theft Deterrence and Copyright Damages Improvement Act of 1999.

(A copy of the PDF decision of the Court is here.)

In addition, kudos to Judge Gertner for being brave and allowing this narrowcast. I’m generally not a huge fan of cameras in the courtroom, especially during trials, as I do believe that it intimidates jurors, affects witness testimony, and may cause grandstanding by judges and attorneys (especially those who see a trial as “free attorney advertising” or judges who are subject to reappointment through popular-vote elections).  But oral argument, particularly in circumstances like this, is a different kettle of fish.  I’m excited to see how the record company attorneys respond.

United States Ditrict Judge Nancy Gertner for Supreme Court?

United States Ditrict Judge Nancy Gertner for Supreme Court?

I first heard of Judge Gertner during the early Blakely/Booker era in 2004 and 2005. She was a pioneer in reacting to the decisions, and has become a sentencing expert.  She’s also a blogger.  She’s a Yale grad, appointed to the bench by President Clinton, and has been very outspoken on a number of civil and criminal justice issues. I would think a jurist of her caliber would be a perfect Supreme Court nominee for President-elect Obama, especially if Justices Stevens, Souter, or Ginsburg were to retire soon.  She’s brilliant, thoughtful, progressive-leaning (in a literal, as well as political, sense–how many other judges have blogs and allow webcasting?), and, as a district judge, she brings insight to the court about the day-to-day practicalities of jurisprudence that no other sitting justice currently has. She may suffer, though, from “too much information-itis,” as with some other long-time Supreme Court hopefuls, just because she’s said too much about too many topics that may seriously frighten center-leaning Democrats and Republicans. But both her future–and this oral argument–will be something to watch.

Advertisements

2 Comments

Filed under Copyrights, Law, Uncategorized

2 responses to “Real CourtTV– Judge Nancy Gerner allows live streaming of oral argument

  1. Pingback: In seeking mandamus writ, what are the record companies afraid of? « Arbitrary & Fanciful

  2. Pingback: The Tenenbaum Strikes Back (Or, at least, writes a press release) « Arbitrary & Fanciful

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s